Strategy
The Local News Crisis: How Campaigns Can Win in Information Deserts
Since 2005, nearly 3,500 American newspapers have closed—more than one-third of all local papers. Today, 213 counties have no local news source at all, and another 1,525 have only one remaining outlet (per the Northwestern Medill Local News Initiative). For political campaigns, this collapse creates both crisis and opportunity: voters are harder to reach through traditional earned media, but campaigns that adapt can dominate information-starved districts.

How Bad Is the Local News Crisis?
The numbers are staggering. Northwestern's Medill School of Journalism documented in their 2025 State of Local News Report that the collapse has accelerated—148 papers closed or merged in the past year alone, roughly 2-3 per week.
The Local News Crisis by the Numbers
| Metric | 2005 | 2025 | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total Newspapers | ~9,000 | ~5,500 | -39% |
| Daily Print Papers | ~1,450 | <1,000 | -31% |
| Print Circulation | 120 million | 38 million | -70% |
| Newspaper Jobs | ~365,000 | ~91,550 | -75% |
| News Desert Counties | ~0 | 213 | +213 |
| Single-Source Counties | ~200 | 1,525 | +662% |
| Unique Newspaper Owners | 3,995 | 1,900 | -52% |
50 million Americans—approximately 1 in 7—now live with limited or no access to local news. Another 249 counties have been identified as having greater than 40% likelihood of becoming news deserts within the next decade.
The shift from independent to chain ownership has accelerated closures. Most 2025 closures came at smaller, independently owned newspapers—not those controlled by large chains—signaling that long-time family publishers are surrendering to economic pressures after decades of fighting to survive.
While over 300 local news startups have launched in the past five years (80% digital-only), the vast majority concentrated in metro areas, leaving rural and less affluent communities further behind.
How Does Local News Decline Affect Political Engagement?
The relationship between local news and democratic participation is well-documented in academic research. When local newspapers close, communities don't just lose information—they lose civic infrastructure.
Research Findings: Local News and Democracy
- Voter Turnout Drops: Research from the Journal of Politics found that citizens in districts with reduced coverage are "less likely to vote, share opinions about candidates, and evaluate representatives." This effect applies regardless of political awareness levels—even highly engaged voters participate less when local news disappears.
- Political Knowledge Declines: Longitudinal research tracking 10,000+ campaign stories found that "reductions in citizens' political knowledge and participation follow declines in coverage about congressional elections." The relationship is causal, not correlational.
- Straight-Ticket Voting Increases: MIT Sloan research found that "if you decrease local news, people engage in straight-ticket voting more." Voters use national news to inform local voting decisions when local coverage disappears.
- Government Accountability Weakens: Studies of Japanese and Swiss municipalities found that increased local newspaper market share correlates with reduced discretionary public spending and better oversight—when local reporters watch, governments behave better.
- Municipal Borrowing Costs Rise: When newspapers close, municipal bond yields increase by 6.4 basis points in secondary markets (Gao, Lee, and Murphy, 2020, Review of Financial Studies). Lenders have difficulty assessing public project quality without local news coverage.
Sources: Journalist's Resource, UNL Digital Commons
For campaigns, these findings have profound implications. In news deserts, voters know less about candidates, care less about local races, and vote more on national party lines. Down-ballot campaigns can't rely on earned media to introduce candidates or define opponents.
Why Does This Matter More for 2026?
The 2026 midterm cycle presents unique challenges. Political ad spending is projected to reach $10.8 billion—with nearly $6 billion flowing into gubernatorial races, state legislative contests, and ballot initiatives. Yet campaigns will be competing for attention in an increasingly fragmented and information-depleted landscape.
The 2026 Information Environment
| Challenge | Impact on Campaigns |
|---|---|
| Fewer journalists covering races | Press releases go unread; earned media opportunities vanish |
| Voters less informed about candidates | Campaigns must do the work newspapers once did |
| National narratives dominate | Local issues harder to break through; races nationalized by default |
| "Pink slime" news sites proliferate | Disinformation fills the void; voter trust in all media declines |
| Social media algorithms prioritize engagement | Sensational national content outcompetes local political news |
The void left by local news doesn't stay empty. "Pink slime" sites—cheaply produced publications that look like local news but serve partisan interests—have proliferated. The New York Times documented networks creating nearly 1,300 such sites (as documented in 2020) with names like "Maine Business Daily" that take money from PR firms and political operatives.
Sources: Campaigns & Elections, MediaRadar
Running in an information desert?
Wave helps campaigns become their own intelligence operation—monitoring local issues, tracking opponent activities, and generating content that fills the void left by vanishing local media.
See how it works →What Do Winning Campaigns Do Differently in News Deserts?
Campaigns that succeed in information-depleted environments don't wait for coverage that won't come. They build direct communication infrastructure that bypasses traditional media entirely.
1. Become the Information Source
When no one else is covering local issues, the campaign that provides useful local information builds credibility and audience. This means:
- Create original local content: Don't just talk about yourself—report on community issues, local government decisions, school board actions, and infrastructure projects. Become the de facto local news source.
- Build email and SMS lists aggressively: In news deserts, your owned channels are your only reliable path to voters. Campaigns with 15,000+ direct subscriber lists in news desert districts regularly outperform campaigns relying on earned media.
- Invest in community social media: Local Facebook groups often fill the void left by newspapers. Campaigns that authentically participate in these communities—not just advertise—build relationships that translate to votes.
2. Dominate Digital Where Traditional Media Has Retreated
With fewer local journalists fact-checking claims and providing context, digital advertising becomes even more powerful—and more responsible campaigns have opportunities to stand out.
Digital Strategy Shifts for News Deserts
| Tactic | Why It Works in News Deserts | Investment Level |
|---|---|---|
| Hyper-local CTV targeting | Geotarget specific ZIP codes with tailored messages about local issues | $50,000-$150,000 |
| Long-form video content | Replace the "getting to know you" role newspapers once played | $15,000-$40,000 |
| Programmatic display on local sites | Many small local sites survive even when newspapers don't | $20,000-$60,000 |
| Podcast advertising | Local podcasts often emerge to fill news voids; loyal audiences | $10,000-$30,000 |
| Nextdoor and local Facebook groups | Where community conversation happens when papers close | $5,000-$15,000 |
Key Insight: In news deserts, voters haven't stopped wanting local information—they've just lost their primary source. Campaigns that provide substantive local content alongside campaign messaging outperform those running pure persuasion ads.
3. Invest Heavily in Field Operations
When voters can't learn about candidates through media, they learn through personal contact. Field operations become exponentially more valuable in news deserts.
- Door-to-door canvassing delivers higher ROI: Research on information environments suggests persuasion effects are meaningfully stronger when voters have fewer competing information sources. Field operations in news deserts may produce larger returns per contact than in media-saturated markets.
- Community events replace press coverage: Town halls, meet-and-greets, and local festival appearances provide the visibility that newspaper profiles once delivered. Consider planning 50 or more events over the campaign cycle.
- Endorsements matter more: Without journalists vetting candidates, voters rely more heavily on trusted community figures. Local endorsements from pastors, business owners, and civic leaders carry outsized weight.
4. Control Your Own Narrative Through Direct Communication
Without local reporters to investigate opponent claims or provide context, campaigns must do this work themselves—and communicate findings directly to voters.
Direct Communication Framework
- Weekly email newsletters: Treat your campaign email list like a newspaper subscription. Provide useful local information alongside campaign updates. Campaigns operating in news deserts often report higher engagement with direct communications — email, text, and door-to-door — as voters have fewer alternative information sources.
- Regular video updates: Candidates doing weekly 2-3 minute video updates on Facebook, YouTube, and Instagram build familiarity that newspaper coverage once provided.
- Opposition research direct to voters: Without journalists to investigate and publish opponent vulnerabilities, campaigns must develop research and distribute findings through their own channels. This requires higher investment in research but creates opportunities for differentiation.
- Rapid response through owned channels: When opponents attack, you can't rely on fair coverage from journalists who don't exist. Your response must reach voters through email, SMS, social media, and digital ads within hours.
Need to build your own intelligence operation?
Wave provides AI-powered opposition research, news monitoring, and content generation tools that help campaigns fill the void left by disappearing local media.
See the platform →How Do You Identify If You're Running in a News Desert?
Before developing strategy, campaigns must assess their local information environment. Not all news deserts are obvious—some districts have technically surviving papers that publish infrequently or have gutted newsrooms.
News Desert Assessment Checklist
- Daily newspaper in district? If no daily paper, you're likely in a news desert or near-desert. Only ~1,000 daily papers remain nationally.
- How many reporters cover local politics? Many surviving papers have 1-2 reporters covering everything. Papers with fewer than 3 reporters rarely provide meaningful political coverage.
- When did the paper last cover a local campaign? Search archives for recent campaign coverage. Many papers have stopped covering down-ballot races entirely.
- What's the paper's ownership? Chain-owned papers (Gannett, Lee, MediaNews) often have severe staffing cuts. Family-owned papers may have more local coverage.
- Is there functioning local TV news? TV news can partially fill newspaper voids, but most local TV focuses on crime, weather, and sports—not political coverage.
- What local digital news sources exist? Search for local news sites, community blogs, or hyperlocal operations that might provide coverage.
Use Northwestern's Local News Initiative database to check the status of news sources in your specific counties.
Budget Implications: What Does a News Desert Campaign Strategy Cost?
Running in a news desert doesn't necessarily cost more—but it requires reallocating budget from earned media activities (that won't work) to direct communication and field operations (that will).
Budget Reallocation: Traditional vs. News Desert Strategy
| Budget Category | Traditional Market | News Desert | Rationale |
|---|---|---|---|
| Earned Media / Press Operations | 15-20% | 5-8% | Fewer journalists to pitch; minimal coverage expected |
| Digital Advertising | 25-35% | 35-45% | Primary channel for voter education in absence of news coverage |
| Field Operations | 15-25% | 25-35% | Personal contact becomes essential for candidate introduction |
| Direct Mail | 10-15% | 15-20% | Voters without local news rely more on mail for information |
| Opposition Research | 3-5% | 5-8% | Must investigate opponents yourself; no journalists doing it |
| Content Production | 5-8% | 10-15% | Original content becomes campaign's main information product |
Key Shift: Traditional campaigns spend significant resources cultivating press relationships and generating earned media. In news deserts, those resources shift to owned and paid channels where you control the message entirely.
The Technology Edge: AI Tools for Information Desert Campaigns
AI-powered campaign tools become even more valuable in news deserts, where campaigns must do work that journalists once performed—researching opponents, monitoring local issues, and producing content at scale.
AI Tools for News Desert Campaigns
| Capability | Traditional Alternative | AI-Powered Approach | News Desert Benefit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Opposition Research | $50,000-$100,000 research firm | Automated monitoring + analysis | Do journalist's job of investigating opponents |
| Local Issue Monitoring | Daily newspaper + staff time | AI aggregation of local sources | Track issues newspapers no longer cover |
| Content Generation | Communications staff ($80K+/year) | AI-assisted content at scale | Fill information void with campaign content |
| Rapid Response | War room + press relations | Automated monitoring + draft responses | Respond directly when no journalists will cover your response |
| Voter Education | Earned media coverage | AI-personalized digital content | Replace newspaper's voter education function |
The advantage compounds: AI-powered tools are particularly valuable in news deserts, where the absence of local reporting means campaigns must generate more of their own intelligence.
The Bottom Line: News Deserts Require Different Playbooks
The local news crisis has fundamentally changed the information environment in which campaigns operate. Strategies optimized for media-rich markets—press releases, editorial board endorsements, earned media campaigns—simply don't translate to news deserts.
Successful campaigns in information-depleted environments:
- Assess their local media landscape honestly before building strategy
- Reallocate budget from earned media to owned and paid channels
- Invest heavily in field operations that provide personal voter contact
- Build direct communication infrastructure (email, SMS, social) from day one
- Become information sources themselves, not just campaigns seeking coverage
- Use AI tools to perform functions that journalists once provided
- Conduct their own opposition research and distribute findings directly to voters
The campaigns that recognize the changed landscape—and adapt their strategies accordingly—will have significant advantages over opponents still running traditional playbooks designed for a media environment that no longer exists.
Filed under strategy on January 5, 2026.