← NotesWave / Notes · DEC 10 2025

Strategy

How Much Can You Raise from Small Donors? The 2025 Guide to Grassroots Fundraising

Small dollar donations now dominate competitive campaigns. This guide breaks down real numbers—platform fees, retention rates, and the tactics that turned $27 averages into billion-dollar war chests.

How Big Is Grassroots Fundraising in 2024?

Bigger than you think. ActBlue processed $3.82 billion in the 2024 cycle. WinRed handled $1.8 billion from 4.5 million individual donors.

According to OpenSecrets, small dollar donations (under $200) represent a major share of individual contributions: 28% for Democrats, 19% for Republicans.

2024 Platform Totals

Platform2024 TotalIndividual Donors
ActBlue$3.82 billion65M+ Express accounts
WinRed$1.8 billion4.5 million

Sources: DataRepublican, ActBlue FEC filings and press reports

The Record-Breaking Moments

Harris campaign launch: $81 million in 24 hours. $100 million over the first weekend from 1.1 million donors. That's the biggest 24-hour period ever on ActBlue.

Trump verdict response: WinRed reported $36 million on May 30th and $34 million on May 31st—$70 million in two days from grassroots donors, as widely reported in contemporaneous news coverage.

What's the Donor Retention Rate for Political Campaigns?

This is where most campaigns fail. Overall donor retention averages just 42.9%. But the numbers vary dramatically by donor type:

Donor Retention by Type

Donor TypeRetention RateLifetime Value
One-time donors7.2%1x (baseline)
Two-time donors16.4%~2x
Three-to-six-time donors38.6%~3x
Seven-plus-time donors83.6%~5x
Recurring monthly donors83-90%5.4x

Sources: Double the Donation, Dataro

Note: These retention benchmarks are drawn from nonprofit fundraising research. Political donor behavior is episodic and tied to election cycles, so actual campaign retention rates may differ substantially.

The key insight: Recurring monthly donors have 5.4x the lifetime value of one-time donors. Converting just 10% more first-time donors to recurring can transform your budget.

The catch: 30-50% of new recurring donors cancel within the first 6 months, based on nonprofit sector data. The recapture rate for lapsed donors is just 4%. Prevention beats cure.

ActBlue vs WinRed: Which Platform Is Better?

If you're a Democrat, you use ActBlue. Republican? WinRed. But knowing the differences helps you optimize.

Platform Comparison

FeatureActBlueWinRed
Processing Fee3.95%3.94% (3.2% over $500)
Launched20042019
Lifetime Total$16 billion+$8.8 billion+
Saved Payment Users65M+ Express accounts8.8M+ donors

Sources: ActBlue Pricing, WinRed Pricing

ActBlue's advantage: 65 million+ Express Lane users with saved payment info. Donors can give in one click—crucial for impulse donations during breaking news.

WinRed's catch-up: Despite launching 15 years later, WinRed's adoption expanded rapidly between 2020 and 2024 as more Republican campaigns adopted the platform. Both now offer A/B testing, recurring management, and CRM integration.

Want to see your donor analytics in one place?

Wave integrates with ActBlue and WinRed to show real-time fundraising performance, donor trends, and optimization recommendations.

See the Platform →

What's a Good Email Fundraising Conversion Rate?

Email is still the workhorse of political fundraising. According to the M+R Benchmarks 2025 Study, nonprofits raised $58 per 1,000 emails sent in 2024.

Good news for political campaigns: While nonpolitical groups saw a 13% decline in email revenue, political groups saw an 8% increase.

Email Benchmarks (2024-2025)

MetricAveragePolitical Sector
Open Rate42.35%Similar (Apple MPP inflated)
Click Rate2%0.83%
Fundraising Click-Through0.48%Similar
Page Completion Rate12%Similar
Revenue per 1,000 Emails$58Higher during peaks

Sources: M+R Benchmarks 2025, MailerLite

Volume is up: Nonprofits sent 62 emails per subscriber in 2024 (9% increase). Email lists grew 4%. More volume = more competition for inbox attention.

How Does AI Improve Fundraising?

78% of organizations used generative AI in their fundraising programs in 2024, according to the M+R Benchmarks study, which primarily surveys nonprofit organizations. Here's what's actually working:

Dynamic Ask Amounts

Old way: Show everyone $25, $50, $100. New way: AI analyzes donor history and shows personalized amounts that maximize both conversion and gift size.

Personalized Subject Lines

Research consistently shows personalized subject lines significantly outperform generic ones in open rates. AI enables this at scale—adjusting not just names but send times, content framing, and emotional hooks.

Donor Scoring

AI can predict which donors are ready to upgrade, which are about to lapse, and which can handle a larger ask. This turns generic blasts into targeted cultivation.

Why Is Monthly Giving So Important?

According to M+R Benchmarks, monthly giving grew 5% in 2024 and now represents 31% of online revenue. One-time giving? Flat.

Monthly Donor Economics

  • First-year retention: 71% still giving at year-end
  • Second-year retention: 61%
  • Lifetime value: 5.4x single-gift donors
  • Early churn risk: 30-50% cancel in first 6 months (based on nonprofit sector data)
  • Lapsed recapture rate: Only 4%

Source: Nonprofit Fundraising

The math: A $25/month donor gives $300/year. With 71% retention, that's $213 in year two, $152 in year three... compared to a one-time $50 donor who has a 7% chance of giving again.

How Do You Raise Money from Small Donors on a Budget?

Start with what you have. You don't need a massive email list or expensive consultants. Here's the playbook:

1. Convert Events to Emails

Every town hall, door knock, and phone call is an email signup opportunity. Ask everyone: "Can I send you updates?" Build your list before you need it.

2. Leverage Deadlines

FEC quarterly deadlines create natural urgency. Your opponent's latest attack creates urgency. Urgency drives action.

3. Make Recurring Easy

Pre-check the recurring box. Frame it as "sustaining member" status. A $10/month donor is worth more than a one-time $100 donor who never comes back.

4. A/B Test Everything

Subject lines, ask amounts, send times. Small improvements compound. A 10% better subject line across 50 emails is transformational.

Your 2026 Fundraising Checklist

The best grassroots programs take 6-12 months to optimize. Start now.

  1. Set up ActBlue/WinRed—Configure Express Lane for one-click donations
  2. Choose your email platform—NGP VAN, or specialized political ESPs with deliverability focus
  3. Connect your CRM—Link donations to voter file and volunteer data
  4. Start list building 12+ months out—Petitions, event signups, social media leads
  5. Build A/B testing habits—Document what works and what doesn't
  6. Set up FEC compliance—Integrate donation tracking with reporting software
  7. Implement AI tools—Ask optimization, send time personalization, segmentation

The Bottom Line

Small dollar fundraising isn't alternative financing anymore—it's the dominant model for competitive campaigns. The Harris campaign's $100 million first weekend proves what's possible when infrastructure meets moment.

The economics are clear: recurring donors generate 5.4x lifetime value with 83%+ retention rates. Invest in converting one-time donors to monthly givers, and your budget becomes predictable.

For 2026, start early, prioritize retention over acquisition, and let AI handle personalization at scale. In an era of record-breaking spending, efficient grassroots fundraising is the sustainable fuel that powers winning campaigns.

Filed under strategy on December 10, 2025.