Wave

A sample baseline. One bookstore, four AI engines.

We ran a baseline on a small independent bookstore that has never worked with us. We've left out its name and details. This is a short version of what you'd get.

We asked four AI engines:

“Does it ship books or take special orders?”

ChatGPT
Yes to both, and pointed to the store’s website and its online storefront.Sources: The store’s site, its online storefront
Gemini
Yes to both, and explained how in-stock and ordered titles are handled.Sources: The store’s site
Perplexity
Yes to both, quoting the store’s site, with the phone number and email to ask.Sources: Six pages on the store’s site, a review site, a local news story
Claude
“I couldn’t find their current policy pages.”
It described how the store shipped during the 2020 shutdown and said special orders were “almost certainly” available.Sources: A 2020 local news story, a book directory

The store’s website shows no text until JavaScript runs. Three engines got through to it anyway. Claude didn’t, and answered from a news story six years old.

How often each engine cited the store’s own website

Across all ten questions, as a share of every link each engine gave.

Gemini39% 13 of 33
Perplexity32% 38 of 117
ChatGPT31% 11 of 35
Claude0% 0 of 44

What else we found

The engines didn’t agree on the best alternative.
Four engines put three different bookstores at the top of the list.
The review counts didn’t agree.
About 750, 766 and 793 Google reviews, depending on the answer.
Other businesses’ pages stood in for the store’s.
One engine took the store’s hours from a coffee shop’s website and the chamber of commerce. Another mentioned other phone numbers and an old listing with the wrong Sunday hours.
One engine answered complaints from Reddit.
Its answer leaned on threads the other engines didn’t use, about issues raised by vendors and job seekers rather than shoppers.

What we’d fix first

  1. Make the website readable without JavaScript, so every engine can take hours, shipping and special orders from the source.
  2. Add one page that answers the shipping, special order and events questions directly.
  3. Correct the old listing with the wrong Sunday hours, and take down the out-of-date holiday notice still on the site.

The ten questions

  • What is the store?
  • Is it any good? What do customers say?
  • What are the best independent bookstores in town?
  • What are the best alternatives to it?
  • What are its hours, and where is it?
  • Is it a nonprofit? Who runs it?
  • What kinds of events does it host?
  • What do customers complain about?
  • Does it ship books or take special orders?
  • How do I contact it?

Asked of ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Claude on November 12, 2026. Shortened from the full baseline.

Want this for your business?

A full baseline covers every question that matters to you, with each answer and its sources. It starts with a short call, and you get it two days later.