We asked four AI engines:
“Does it ship books or take special orders?”
- ChatGPT
- Yes to both, and pointed to the store’s website and its online storefront.Sources: The store’s site, its online storefront
- Gemini
- Yes to both, and explained how in-stock and ordered titles are handled.Sources: The store’s site
- Perplexity
- Yes to both, quoting the store’s site, with the phone number and email to ask.Sources: Six pages on the store’s site, a review site, a local news story
- Claude
“I couldn’t find their current policy pages.”
It described how the store shipped during the 2020 shutdown and said special orders were “almost certainly” available.Sources: A 2020 local news story, a book directory
The store’s website shows no text until JavaScript runs. Three engines got through to it anyway. Claude didn’t, and answered from a news story six years old.
How often each engine cited the store’s own website
Across all ten questions, as a share of every link each engine gave.
| Gemini | 39% 13 of 33 | |
|---|---|---|
| Perplexity | 32% 38 of 117 | |
| ChatGPT | 31% 11 of 35 | |
| Claude | 0% 0 of 44 |
What else we found
- The engines didn’t agree on the best alternative.
- Four engines put three different bookstores at the top of the list.
- The review counts didn’t agree.
- About 750, 766 and 793 Google reviews, depending on the answer.
- Other businesses’ pages stood in for the store’s.
- One engine took the store’s hours from a coffee shop’s website and the chamber of commerce. Another mentioned other phone numbers and an old listing with the wrong Sunday hours.
- One engine answered complaints from Reddit.
- Its answer leaned on threads the other engines didn’t use, about issues raised by vendors and job seekers rather than shoppers.
What we’d fix first
- Make the website readable without JavaScript, so every engine can take hours, shipping and special orders from the source.
- Add one page that answers the shipping, special order and events questions directly.
- Correct the old listing with the wrong Sunday hours, and take down the out-of-date holiday notice still on the site.
The ten questions
- What is the store?
- Is it any good? What do customers say?
- What are the best independent bookstores in town?
- What are the best alternatives to it?
- What are its hours, and where is it?
- Is it a nonprofit? Who runs it?
- What kinds of events does it host?
- What do customers complain about?
- Does it ship books or take special orders?
- How do I contact it?