Ask AI about a candidate's controversies. It cites the other party's committee nearly four times as often as the candidate's campaign.
And half the dated news it cites was published before 2026.
6,174 answers about the controversies of 114 House candidates, from ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity, Aug 17 to Nov 4, 2026.For 11 weeks, we asked the three biggest AI engines every few days what a voter would ask about the candidates in the closest House races, including what controversies each one faced. We saved every source they cited. We found:
- 26% of controversy answers cited the opposing party's House campaign committee. 7% cited the candidate's own campaign site.
- For 81 of 114 candidates, the other party's committee was cited more often than their campaign. For 36, their campaign site was never cited on a controversy question.
- Half the dated news articles cited in controversy answers were published before 2026. On who's running and the issues, it was 6% or less.
- Ask who a candidate is, and AI goes to the candidate's own sites. Ask what's wrong with them, and it mostly doesn't.
Most candidates.
candidates saw the other party's committee cited more often than their own campaign site.
The candidate's side, counted every way.
Every engine.
The controversy record was written before this year.
Many news sites put the publication date in the page address. We used it to date the articles AI cited.
Old news, only on controversies.
Some of it is very old.
were published in 2024 or earlier. 18% in 2022 or earlier.
ChatGPT leans on it most.
Ask who they are, and AI asks the candidate.
On a plain profile question, the same engines cite the candidate's own sites in most answers.
Profiles look different.
Same candidates, same engines.
of profile answers cited the campaign site, against controversy answers.
How we did it
From Aug 17 to Nov 4, we asked ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity the questions a voter would ask about the candidates in each of the 100 closest House races every few days, and asked each time for authoritative sources. We saved every answer and every source it cited, and left out login walls and non-answers. We used the free version of each engine.
We took each candidate's campaign site from their Ballotpedia page, and checked the rest by hand. Official sites are the candidate's House.gov page; most of the 114 candidates were incumbents. Committee pages are the DCCC and NRCC sites. An article counts as dated when its address carries a year and month, as most news sites' do.
We're reporting what AI cited, not whether any claim is true. Some controversies are old by nature; the finding is that the record AI reads on them was mostly written by others, and much of it before 2026.
Our other studies of the same races: which sites AI cited and which candidates it named.
Get the counts: summary (CSV)
Is AI telling your side?
When voters ask AI about you, it answers from whatever record it can find. In two days you get a baseline: what every channel says about you, which sources it comes from, and the first one we would fix.